Sourcing agent alternative
MakeMine vs a sourcing agent
A sourcing agent finds you a factory. MakeMine buys from the factory and owns the order through production, import and, if you want it, fulfillment. Here is how the two compare, including when an agent is the better choice.
The short answer
A sourcing agent finds and introduces factories for a fee that is often built into the unit price, and your brand still runs the order, freight, customs and fulfillment. MakeMine buys from the factory, owns the order through production and import as importer of record, and can ship to your customers from our Charlotte fulfillment center.
Choose an agent if you only want factory introductions and have people to run everything else. Choose MakeMine if you want one accountable partner from factory to customer, with the full landed cost in front of you before you commit.
Working with brands since 2018, about 110 so far. Products we've made are sold at Nordstrom, REI Co-op, Shopbop, Anthropologie, Target and Dick's Sporting Goods.
Key differences
How the two models compare on the things that decide cost, risk and time. Practices vary from agent to agent, so read the agent column as typical, not universal.
| Compared on | Sourcing agent | MakeMine |
|---|---|---|
| What you are paying for | Factory introductions and coordination | Sourcing, production, import and optional fulfillment, run as one system |
| Who owns the order | You place the order with the factory. The agent coordinates. | We buy from the factory and own the order through production and import. |
| Importer of record | You, usually through your customs broker | MakeMine |
| Who you pay | The factory, often overseas, plus the agent's fee | MakeMine, a US company, by ACH, wire or card |
| How they are paid | Often a margin built into the unit price, so you see one number and no separate fee. Some bill a commission or retainer instead. | Per-program pricing, set out before you approve anything |
| Cost visibility | You often see one unit price, not what the factory was paid | Product cost, freight, duties and landed cost shown separately on the quote, with no surprise sampling fees |
| What duty is charged on | The full invoiced price, including any margin built into it | The true factory cost. As importer of record, we declare what the factory was paid. |
| Quality control | Varies, from factory visits to booking a third-party inspection firm | Inspections, lab and compliance testing, and problems fixed at the root |
| Freight and customs | Usually yours, through a freight forwarder and a customs broker | We book freight and clear customs |
| Fulfillment | Not offered | Optional DTC and wholesale fulfillment from our Charlotte fulfillment center |
| Where you see status | Email, chat apps and spreadsheets | One app with quotes, tech packs, POs, samples, production status, shipments and inventory |
| Your current factories | Agents usually work through their own contacts | We manage factories you already use, our established factory partners, or both |
| Presence on the factory floor | Often a strength. A local agent can be at one factory every day. | Factory partners visited in person, with inspections at set production milestones |
| Product range | Whatever the agent covers, including hard goods | Apparel, bags, hats, textiles and sporting goods, plus US-made personal care |
How a sourcing agent works
A sourcing agent is a person or firm, usually based in the producing country, who finds factories, negotiates price, follows up on production and sometimes checks quality for you. Your brand still contracts with the factory, pays for the goods and imports them.
Agents, agencies and buying offices
An independent agent is often one person or a small office covering one country. A sourcing agency is a larger firm with quality staff and offices in several regions. A buying office works for one brand or a small group of them. The work is similar. The scale and the fee model are what differ.
How agents get paid
There is no reliable going rate to quote, because many agents never show their fee. Overseas agents in particular often quote one unit price with their margin built in, so you never see what the factory was paid.
That has a second cost. The unit price on the invoice is the value declared to customs, so you pay duty on the agent's margin as well as on the goods.
Some agents bill a separate commission, flat fee or retainer instead, which you can see. Before you sign, ask which model applies, ask for the factory's own quote in writing, and ask whether the factory pays the agent anything.
How MakeMine works
You send what you want made. We run everything from the quote to your customer, and you decide and approve each step in the app.
Send the product. A tech pack, a sketch, a reference sample or a product you already sell.
Get a quote. From our established factory partners or your own factories, with landed cost and lead time.
Approve or adjust. We negotiate with the factory until the cost and timing work.
Sample. Your feedback is recorded in the app and built into future orders.
Bulk production. Run against milestones, with inspections and testing.
Freight and customs. We book freight and clear customs as importer of record.
Fulfillment, if you want it. We ship DTC and wholesale orders from our Charlotte fulfillment center.
When a sourcing agent is the better choice
An agent is a good fit when what you need is access to factories, not someone to run the program.
You only want introductions
If you have a production lead who will run sampling, freight, customs and inspections, paying an agent to find factories can cost less than a partner that does all of it.
You need someone at one factory every day
A local agent can stand on one factory floor daily. We visit our factory partners in person and inspect at set milestones, which is not the same thing.
Your product is outside our categories
We make apparel, bags, hats, textiles, sporting goods and US-made personal care. For electronics, furniture or other hard goods, a specialist agent in that region will serve you better.
Unit price is the only number that matters
For a high-volume, single-SKU program where you already run logistics in-house, buying through an agent or direct from the factory can win on unit price.
Where the agent model leaves gaps
Most agents introduce the factory and step back. The risk and the coordination stay with your brand.
You are the importer of record, so customs errors, duty and compliance problems are yours. Quality claims run against a factory you may never have visited.
Someone on your team still coordinates the factory, the agent, a freight forwarder, a customs broker, an inspection firm and a fulfillment provider. Each sends its own invoice, and a mistake at one handoff usually shows up at the next.
When the fee is built into the unit price, you can't see what the factory was paid, and you pay duty on the markup as well as the goods. That does not make an agent dishonest, but it does mean the number you are negotiating is not the real cost.
Status lives in email threads, chat apps and spreadsheets, so the full picture sits in one person's head.
Compare landed cost, not unit price
The factory price is one line. This is who handles and bills each of the others.
| Cost line | Sourcing agent | MakeMine |
|---|---|---|
| Product | One unit price, often with the agent's fee built in, so the true factory cost stays hidden | Product cost on the quote, paid to MakeMine |
| Sourcing fee | Often built into the unit price, where you can't see it. Some agents bill it separately. | Per-program pricing, set out before you approve, with no surprise sampling fees |
| Inspections and testing | Usually a separate inspection firm and lab, booked by you or the agent | Managed by us as part of production |
| Freight | Your freight forwarder, on a separate invoice | Booked by us and billed separately |
| Duties and customs | Your customs broker, with you liable as importer of record and duty charged on the full invoiced price | Cleared by us as importer of record, with duty charged on the true factory cost. Duties are estimated upfront and billed separately. |
| Fulfillment | A separate fulfillment provider and contract | Optional, from our Charlotte fulfillment center, with no annual contract |
| Your team's time | Someone coordinates the factory, agent, forwarder, broker and warehouse | You decide and approve in the app. We run the rest. |
| Mistakes between handoffs | Fall between vendors, and each points to the next | One party accountable from factory to customer |
We are not always cheaper on unit price. Put the landed cost per unit and the hours your team spends next to each other, not the factory price alone.
Which one fits your brand
Choose a sourcing agent if
- You only want a factory introduction and will manage the rest yourself.
- You have an operations or production lead to run freight, customs, inspections and fulfillment.
- Your product is outside apparel, accessories, textiles, sporting goods and personal care.
- You need someone physically at one factory every day.
Choose MakeMine if
- You want one accountable partner from factory to customer.
- Production currently sits on a founder, designer or ops lead on top of their real job.
- You want the full landed cost and lead time before you commit.
- You want production status, shipments and inventory in one place instead of across vendors.
Already have factories you like? Keep them. We can manage the factories you already use, add our established factory partners alongside them, or both.
What brands say
“Their ability to find the factories and materials we need, manage all the details, and bring our visions to fruition is something we as a brand have never experienced.”
“We see samples quicker, get responses within 1-2 days, and we have been allocating more and more business back to you.”
Related
Apparel production management
Manage factories you already use, our factory partners, or both through one workflow.
Switch apparel manufacturers
Move production away from a factory that isn't working without rebuilding the whole program.
Apparel sourcing company
Established factory relationships plus managed sourcing, development, production and delivery.
Fulfillment
DTC and wholesale fulfillment from our Charlotte fulfillment center, with or without our production.
Other comparisons
MakeMine vs an apparel consultant
A consultant manages factories part-time. We run production through fulfillment so they can focus on design.
MakeMine vs going factory direct
Factory direct wins on unit price. We own the order through import and fulfillment. Where each one fits.
MakeMine vs hiring a production manager
A hire adds one person. We add leverage, quality control, import and fulfillment, and work alongside the person you have.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a sourcing agent charge?
There is no reliable going rate, because many agents never show their fee. Overseas agents often quote one unit price with their margin built in, so you don't see what the factory was paid, and you pay duty on that margin too. Others bill a separate commission, flat fee or retainer. Ask which model applies and ask for the factory's own quote in writing. Then add freight, duties, inspections and your team's time to see the real cost.
Do you pay duty on a sourcing agent's markup?
Often, yes. When an agent or trading company invoices you one unit price with their fee built in, that full price is the value declared to customs, so duty is charged on the markup as well as the goods. MakeMine is importer of record and declares the true factory cost, so duty is charged on what the factory was paid, not on a markup.
Is MakeMine a sourcing agent?
No. We do the work brands often hire an agent for, finding and vetting factories, but we don't stop at the introduction. We buy from the factory, own the order through production and import as importer of record, and can fulfill orders to your customers. You pay MakeMine, a US company, and see every step in our app.
Do I need a sourcing agent to manufacture clothing?
No. Brands manufacture clothing three ways: direct with a factory, through a sourcing agent, or with a partner that runs production end to end, like MakeMine. Going direct works if you have production experience and time. An agent helps you find factories but leaves the rest to you. If no one on your team owns production full time, an end-to-end partner is usually the safer choice.
What is the difference between a sourcing agent and a trading company?
A sourcing agent works for you. They find factories, you buy from the factory, and you pay the agent a fee. A trading company buys from factories and resells to you at a markup, often without telling you which factory made your goods. MakeMine also buys from the factory, so the honest difference is what comes with it: a US company as importer of record, landed cost on the quote, every step visible in the app, the option to use your own factories, and fulfillment.
Is MakeMine cheaper than a sourcing agent?
Not always on unit price. A factory price found through an agent can be lower than our product cost. We place volume pooled across many brands, which earns better pricing, terms and factory priority than one growing brand gets alone. Beyond that, our case is the landed cost and the work around it: duty charged on the true factory cost, freight, inspections, fixing mistakes, and the hours your team spends coordinating vendors. The simplest test is to send us one style you make today and compare the full numbers.
Can MakeMine work with the factory my agent found?
Yes. If a factory is performing well, keep it. We can manage the factories you already use, add our established factory partners alongside them, or both. See how we handle production across existing factories.
Can I switch from a sourcing agent partway through a season?
Yes. Most brands start with one style or one production run while their current orders finish. There is no annual contract, so you can compare results before you move more of your line.
Put one style side by side
Send us a style you make today. We'll quote it with full landed cost and lead time, so you can compare it with what your agent and vendors cost you now.
