Factory direct alternative
MakeMine vs going factory direct
Buying direct from the factory usually gets you the lowest unit price. MakeMine buys from the factory and owns the order through production, import and, if you want it, fulfillment. Here is how the two compare on landed cost, risk and time, including when going direct is the better choice.
The short answer
Going factory direct usually gets you the lowest unit price, and your brand takes on everything around it: sampling, quality checks, freight, customs as importer of record and fulfillment, each with its own vendor. MakeMine buys from the factory, owns the order through production and import, and can ship to your customers from our Charlotte fulfillment center.
Choose factory direct if you have an experienced production lead, a stable factory and enough volume to matter to it. Choose MakeMine if production sits on someone with another job, and you want the full landed cost in front of you before you commit.
Working with brands since 2018, about 110 so far. Products we've made are sold at Nordstrom, REI Co-op, Shopbop, Anthropologie, Target and Dick's Sporting Goods.
Key differences
How the two compare on the things that decide cost, risk and time. Factories vary, so read the factory direct column as typical, not universal.
| Compared on | Factory direct | MakeMine |
|---|---|---|
| What the quote covers | Product cost, usually FOB, meaning loaded at the port in the factory's country | Product cost, freight, duties and landed cost shown separately on the quote |
| Unit price | Often the lowest number you will see | Not always the lowest. Compare landed cost, not unit price. |
| Your leverage with the factory | Your volume alone. A smaller order can lose line time to bigger customers in peak season. | Volume pooled across many brands, which earns better pricing, terms and factory priority |
| Who owns the order | You. You contract with the factory and carry the risk if it goes wrong. | We buy from the factory and own the order through production and import. |
| Importer of record | You, with your own customs broker and customs bond. Some factories quote DDP and clear through their own forwarder. | MakeMine |
| Who you pay | The factory, usually by international wire, often with a deposit when you place the order | MakeMine, a US company, by ACH, wire or card |
| Quality control | Whatever you arrange: the factory's own checks, your visits, or an inspection firm you book | Inspections, lab and compliance testing, and problems fixed at the root |
| When something goes wrong | You negotiate a fix or credit with the factory, often after you have paid in full | We take it up with the factory and fix the cause so it doesn't repeat |
| Freight and customs | Your freight forwarder and customs broker, on separate invoices | We book freight and clear customs |
| Fulfillment | A separate fulfillment provider, or your own warehouse | Optional DTC and wholesale fulfillment from our Charlotte fulfillment center |
| Where you see status | Email, WhatsApp or WeChat threads and spreadsheets, across time zones | One app with quotes, tech packs, POs, samples, production status, shipments and inventory |
| Factory relationship | Direct. You know the owner and the people running your line. | We manage factories you already use, our established factory partners, or both |
| Product range | Whatever that factory makes | Apparel, bags, hats, textiles and sporting goods, plus US-made personal care |
What going factory direct involves
Going factory direct means your brand finds the factory, places the purchase order and pays for it, with no agent or partner in between. It can work well. The factory price is also only one part of what the product costs you.
What a factory quote covers
Most overseas factories quote FOB, free on board. The price covers making the goods and loading them at the factory's port. From there the cost is yours: ocean or air freight, duty, customs broker fees, the merchandise processing fee, your customs bond, port charges and trucking to your fulfillment center.
Samples, lab testing and third-party inspections are usually billed separately too. None of them show up in the unit price you are comparing.
Who is importer of record
When you buy FOB, your brand is the importer of record. You are legally responsible for the declared value, the HTS code, the country of origin and the duty owed. A bulk production run is almost always a formal entry, and formal entries need a customs bond.
Some factories quote DDP, delivered duty paid, and clear customs through their own forwarder. That is simpler, but ask who is named as importer of record and what value is declared. If the entry is wrong, it is your goods that sit at the port.
To see what duty your styles carry, try our apparel HTS code finder.
Leverage as one growing brand
A factory plans its lines around its biggest customers. When capacity is tight, a smaller order can slip, and minimums, pricing and terms reflect your volume alone.
Many overseas factories ask for a deposit when you place the order and the balance before the goods ship. By the time you open the boxes, the order is usually paid for, so a quality problem becomes a negotiation over a credit on the next order.
How MakeMine works
You send what you want made. We run everything from the quote to your customer, and you decide and approve each step in the app.
Send the product. A tech pack, a sketch, a reference sample or a product you already sell.
Get a quote. From our established factory partners or the factory you use today, with landed cost and lead time.
Approve or adjust. We negotiate with the factory until the cost and timing work.
Sample. Your feedback is recorded in the app and built into future orders.
Bulk production. Run against milestones, with inspections and testing.
Freight and customs. We book freight and clear customs as importer of record.
Fulfillment, if you want it. We ship DTC and wholesale orders from our Charlotte fulfillment center.
When going factory direct is the better choice
Going direct is a good fit when you already have the people and the volume to run it well.
Unit price decides everything
For a high-volume, single-SKU program, a direct factory price is hard to beat, especially if you already run freight and customs in-house.
You have an experienced production lead
If someone on your team runs sampling, inspections, freight and customs full time, and does it well, much of what we do is already covered.
One stable factory and a simple product
A product that one factory has made well for years, with someone who has the time to manage it, may not need a partner.
Your product is outside our categories
We make apparel, bags, hats, textiles, sporting goods and US-made personal care. For electronics, furniture or other hard goods, go direct or find a specialist.
Where going direct leaves gaps
The factory makes the product. Everything around it lands on your brand.
Someone on your team becomes the link between the factory, a freight forwarder, a customs broker, an inspection firm and a fulfillment center. Each sends its own invoice, and a mistake at one handoff usually shows up at the next.
Quality problems tend to surface after the goods are paid for and on the water. The fix is a credit on the next order or a long negotiation across time zones, while your launch date moves.
As importer of record, customs errors and penalties are yours, even when a forwarder or broker filed the entry.
At the growing brands we work with, that link is usually a founder, a designer or an ops lead doing it on top of their real job. That cost never shows up on the factory quote.
Compare landed cost, not unit price
The factory price is one line. This is who handles and bills each of the others.
| Cost line | Factory direct | MakeMine |
|---|---|---|
| Product | The factory's FOB price, usually the lowest number on paper | Product cost on the quote, paid to MakeMine |
| Samples | Billed by the factory, on terms that vary from factory to factory | Set out upfront, with no surprise sampling fees |
| Inspections and testing | An inspection firm and a lab, booked and paid by you | Managed by us as part of production |
| Freight | Your freight forwarder, on a separate invoice | Booked by us and billed separately |
| Duties and customs | Your customs broker and customs bond, with you liable as importer of record | Cleared by us as importer of record. Duties are estimated upfront and billed separately. |
| Fulfillment | A separate fulfillment provider and contract | Optional, from our Charlotte fulfillment center, with no annual contract |
| Your team's time | Someone runs the factory, forwarder, broker, inspection firm and fulfillment center | You decide and approve in the app. We run the rest. |
| Mistakes and rework | Yours to negotiate with the factory, usually after you have paid | One party accountable from factory to customer, with problems fixed at the root |
We are not always cheaper on unit price. Put the landed cost per unit and the hours your team spends side by side, not the factory price alone.
Which one fits your brand
Choose factory direct if
- You run a high-volume program where unit price decides everything.
- You have an experienced production lead who handles freight, customs and inspections.
- You have one stable factory and a product that rarely changes.
- Your product is outside apparel, accessories, textiles, sporting goods and personal care.
Choose MakeMine if
- Production sits on a founder, designer or ops lead on top of their real job.
- You want the full landed cost and lead time before you commit.
- You want the pricing and priority of pooled volume without having to grow into it.
- You want one accountable partner from factory to customer, with status in one place.
Already buying direct from a factory you trust? Keep it. We can manage the factories you already use, add our established factory partners alongside them, or both.
What brands say
“We see samples quicker, get responses within 1-2 days, and we have been allocating more and more business back to you.”
“Adding MakeMine to our team cut my costs by 30% and improved our product quality. We can finally trust goods will be delivered on time.”
Related
Apparel production management
Manage factories you already use, our factory partners, or both through one workflow.
Freight and customs
Freight booked and customs cleared, with MakeMine as importer of record.
Apparel HTS code finder
HTS codes and the full US duty stack for 100+ garments made in China.
Switch apparel manufacturers
Move production away from a factory that isn't working without rebuilding the whole program.
Other comparisons
MakeMine vs a sourcing agent
Agents introduce factories for a fee. We own the order through import and fulfillment. Where each one fits.
MakeMine vs an apparel consultant
A consultant manages factories part-time. We run production through fulfillment so they can focus on design.
MakeMine vs hiring a production manager
A hire adds one person. We add leverage, quality control, import and fulfillment, and work alongside the person you have.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to buy direct from the factory?
On unit price, usually yes. On landed cost, not always. A factory quote is usually FOB, so freight, duty, customs fees, inspections, testing and fulfillment come on top, plus the time someone on your team spends running it all. MakeMine places volume pooled across many brands, which earns better pricing, terms and factory priority than one growing brand gets alone. The simplest test is to send us one style you make today and compare the full numbers.
What does a factory's FOB price include?
FOB, free on board, covers making the goods and loading them at the factory's port. It doesn't include ocean or air freight, US duty, the merchandise processing fee, customs broker fees, your customs bond, port charges or trucking to your fulfillment center. Samples, lab testing and inspections are often billed separately as well.
Who is the importer of record when I buy direct from a factory?
If you buy FOB or ex-works, your brand is the importer of record, responsible for the declared value, HTS code, country of origin and duty. If the factory quotes DDP, its forwarder usually clears customs, so ask who is named as importer of record and what value is declared. When you work with MakeMine, MakeMine is the importer of record.
Do I need a customs broker and a customs bond to import from a factory?
You need a bond. Formal entry generally applies to shipments valued over $2,500, which covers almost any bulk production run, and formal entries require a customs bond. A broker is not legally required, but most brands use a licensed customs broker to file. For the goods we produce, MakeMine clears customs as importer of record, so you need neither.
Do factories give priority to bigger customers?
Usually, yes. A factory plans line time around its largest customers, so a smaller order can slip in peak season, and minimums and pricing reflect your volume alone. MakeMine places volume pooled across many brands, which earns better pricing, terms and factory priority than one growing brand gets on its own.
Can MakeMine work with the factory I already buy from?
Yes. If a factory is performing well, keep it. We can manage the factories you already use, add our established factory partners alongside them, or both. See how we handle production across existing factories.
Isn't MakeMine just a markup on the factory price?
Our pricing is per program and set out before you approve anything, so you can compare it line by line with what you pay now. What comes with it is the work a direct order leaves to you: inspections and testing, freight, customs as importer of record, landed cost on the quote, problems fixed at the root, and every step in one app. You pay MakeMine, a US company, and you approve every quote and sample.
Can I try MakeMine without moving my whole line?
Yes. Most brands start with one style or one production run alongside their current factory. There is no annual contract, so you can compare results before you move more of your line.
Put one style side by side
Send us a style you buy direct today. We'll quote it with full landed cost and lead time, so you can compare it with what the factory, freight, customs and your team's time cost you now.
